Here’s a bold statement: ranking the Knives Out movies is no easy feat, especially when each installment brings something uniquely captivating to the table. But with the recent release of Wake Up Dead Man: A Knives Out Mystery on Netflix, it’s time to dive into the debate. As a die-hard fan of the franchise, I’ve revisited all three films, and let me tell you, it’s a mystery worth solving: which of Benoit Blanc’s cases truly takes the crown? But here’s where it gets controversial—my ranking might surprise you.
3. Glass Onion (2022)
Glass Onion is a blast, no doubt. The star-studded cast, led by the mesmerizing Janelle Monáe, delivers in spades. The reveal of why Benoit Blanc is invited to the lavish getaway is a stroke of genius, and the cameo of his partner adds a delightful layer. Yet, for me, it falls slightly behind the others. Is it the lighter, almost sillier tone? The less likable ensemble of characters? Or perhaps it’s the lingering reminder of the COVID era that keeps it from topping my list. Don’t get me wrong—it’s still a fantastic ride, but it’s my least favorite of the trio. And this is the part most people miss—while it’s bigger in scale, it doesn’t quite match the intimacy and charm of the others. (Rotten Tomatoes score: 91%)
2. Knives Out (2019)
Rian Johnson’s original masterpiece set the bar high. With its tightly woven plot, an instantly iconic Benoit Blanc, and a New England estate dripping with character, it’s a modern homage to Agatha Christie that hits all the right notes. The mystery of Harlan Thrombey’s death is a rollercoaster, and the film’s critical acclaim—including an Oscar nod for Best Original Screenplay—speaks volumes. Revisiting it years later, its charm hasn’t faded. It’s a delight from start to finish, though I’ll admit, it narrowly misses the top spot in my heart. (Rotten Tomatoes score: 97%)
1. Wake Up Dead Man (2025)
Here’s the controversial part—I’m placing Wake Up Dead Man at the top, and I know some fans might disagree. But hear me out. While it’s a close call with the original, this installment edges ahead for me. The cast is phenomenal, the tone is darker and more grounded than Glass Onion, and it’s hands-down the funniest of the bunch. After two theater viewings, I’m convinced it’s the best, though I’ll admit, recency bias might be at play. Still, my gut says this one’s a winner. (Rotten Tomatoes score: 92%)
So, there you have it—my ranking of the Knives Out trilogy. But what do you think? Is Wake Up Dead Man truly the best, or does another film deserve the top spot? Let’s debate in the comments—I’m ready to hear your take!
